Generally, no. Cost of goods sold covers what it costs to make or buy the products you sold: materials, packaging that's part of the product, inbound freight, and direct labor. Shopify's subscription and app fees are operating expenses. Payment processing fees are usually treated as selling or merchant expenses, though some accountants put them in COGS. Outbound shipping labels are usually a selling or fulfillment expense. Shopify's own profit reports don't include any of these; they use only your cost per item.
This is general information, not tax advice. Your accountant decides how your business classifies each cost.
The short version
| Cost | Usually |
|---|---|
| Ingredients, materials, parts | COGS |
| Packaging that's part of the product (jar, label) | COGS |
| Inbound freight and duties | COGS |
| Direct labor making the product | COGS (depends on your method) |
| Shopify subscription | Operating expense |
| Shopify apps and themes | Operating expense |
| Payment processing fees | Selling or merchant expense (sometimes COGS) |
| Outbound shipping labels | Selling or fulfillment expense |
| Shipping boxes and mailers | Selling expense (sometimes COGS) |
Why it matters
COGS sets gross margin, the number you use to price products and compare them. Put fees in COGS and every product looks less profitable than it is to make; leave real product costs out and it looks more profitable. Whichever way your accountant classifies a cost, do it the same way every month so margins compare.
What Shopify's reports include
Shopify's gross profit and margin reports use cost per item, the number you type on each variant, recorded at the time of sale. They don't subtract Shopify fees, payment processing or shipping. To see true profit per order, add those yourself in a spreadsheet or your accounting system. Shopify margin report covers reading Shopify's version.
A made-up example
Kalapana Kava sells a $28 jar. Its costs per jar:
| Cost | Amount | Where it goes |
|---|---|---|
| Kava root, jar, lid, label | $6.40 | COGS |
| Inbound freight on root | $0.35 | COGS |
| Payment processing (about 3%) | $0.84 | Selling expense |
| Share of shipping label | $4.10 | Fulfillment expense |
| Share of Shopify plan and apps | $0.60 | Operating expense |
Gross margin: ($28 − $6.75) ÷ $28 = 76%. Profit after selling costs is much lower, about $15.70 before overheads. Both numbers are useful; they answer different questions.
Keeping it tidy in the books
Shopify pays out sales minus fees, so the deposit in your bank isn't your revenue. Record the full sale, then the fees separately, using Shopify's payout reports to split them. Keep one account for platform costs (plan, apps, themes), one for payment processing, and one for shipping labels. At year end your accountant can move any of them into or out of COGS in one line, rather than unpicking a year of mixed entries.
Where this stops working
Getting the categories right only helps if the COGS number itself is right. For a maker, that means each batch's real cost: ingredients at what you paid, yields, waste and freight. A cost per item typed in once a year makes the cleanest classification meaningless. Shopify cost of goods sold and Shopify production cost cover working it out.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack for Shopify runs inside your Shopify admin and works out the product side of COGS from each batch: ingredients and packaging at what they cost, including freight, in FIFO layers, with actual against standard cost. Stock value by site and month is ready for your accountant. Free for 14 days.
