Most skincare and beauty products are cosmetics under US law. To sell them on Shopify, label each one with its name, net quantity, ingredients in descending order, your name and place of business, and a US address, phone number or website for reaction reports, which the 2022 cosmetics law (MoCRA) added. Products that claim to treat or prevent something, like sunscreen, acne treatment or antiperspirant, are drugs and follow drug rules. True soap, made and sold only as soap, is outside the cosmetic rules altogether.
This is general information, not legal advice.
The short version
- Lotions, creams, lip balm, makeup and perfume: cosmetics.
- Sunscreen, acne treatment, antiperspirant, dandruff shampoo: drugs, with drug labels and rules.
- Soap made from fats and lye, labelled and sold only as soap: not a cosmetic. Moisturizing or deodorizing claims make it one.
- Cosmetic label: name, net quantity, ingredients in descending order, maker's name and place, adverse event contact.
- Small businesses under MoCRA's threshold skip facility registration and product listing, but not label rules.
Cosmetic or drug?
| Product and claim | Category |
|---|---|
| "Moisturizing body butter" | Cosmetic |
| "SPF 30 sunscreen lotion" | Drug |
| "Clears acne" | Drug |
| "Handmade goat milk soap" sold only as soap | Soap, not a cosmetic |
| "Moisturizing goat milk soap" | Cosmetic |
The claim decides, including claims on your Shopify product page.
The label
Ingredients go in descending order of amount; those at 1% or less can follow in any order, and colors go last. Fragrance can be listed as "fragrance" until FDA's fragrance allergen rule is final. The label needs a domestic contact for adverse event reports. Put the same ingredient list on the product page. Cosmetic labeling requirements covers each part in depth.
MoCRA for small makers
MoCRA's small business definition is under $1,000,000 in average yearly US cosmetic sales over three years, adjusted for inflation. Small businesses are exempt from facility registration and product listing, with exceptions for certain product types, such as those applied to the eye. Everyone needs the label contact, must report serious adverse events, and should keep records showing the product is safe.
Products that need extra care
- Eye-area products like mascara and eyeliner are excluded from MoCRA's small business exemption.
- Products for babies and children draw closer attention from buyers and regulators.
- Water-based products (lotions, creams) need a preservative system that works; ask your supplier for test data or have the formula tested.
- Anything with a claim beyond appearance, like "anti-aging" with a medical edge, can tip into drug territory.
A made-up example
Kōloa Botanicals makes body butter, lip balm and a cold-process soap. The soap is labelled only "Handmade Soap", so it's soap. The body butter says "Moisturizing", so it's a cosmetic with a full ingredient list and a contact line. When a customer reports a rash from the body butter, the batch code on the tin leads to batch 1011, its shea butter lot and its essential oil lot, recorded the day it was made.
Where this stops working
Shopify sells the jar and keeps no batch records: no lot codes, no ingredient lots, no record of which customers got which batch. Those are the records an adverse event report or a supplier recall depends on. Shopify lot numbers and Shopify raw materials inventory cover keeping them.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack for Shopify runs inside your Shopify admin and keeps versioned formulas, batches with lot codes and dates, which ingredient lots each batch used, and which orders each batch went to, for skincare as much as food. It keeps records; it doesn't write labels or make you compliant. Free for 14 days.
