Lip balm goes in a twist-up tube: a 0.15-ounce tube with a cap, filled hot on a filling tray, with a wraparound label. A paperboard push-up tube skips the plastic but costs more and wants a firmer balm that pushes up cleanly; a slide tin suits a softer balm applied with a finger; and a countertop display box of 24 tubes is what gift shops set by the register. The label is a cosmetic label, on a tiny package. In the example below, a Pennsylvania apothecary prices four options: 36 cents to 69 cents a package.
The short version
- Twist-up tubes with a wraparound label: the standard.
- Paperboard tubes skip the plastic, cost more, want a firmer balm.
- Slide tins suit a softer balm.
- Display boxes of 24 sell by a shop's register.
- A cosmetic label: identity, net weight, ingredients, name and place.
- Leave out SPF and healing claims.
- TaroStack puts the tube and label in each flavor's cost. More below.
The options
| Option | Plastic-free | Applied by | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plastic tube and label | No | Twist-up | Markets, online |
| Paperboard push-up tube | Yes | Push-up | Plastic-free shops |
| Slide tin | Yes | Finger | Softer balms, gifts |
| Tube in a display box of 24 | No | Twist-up | Gift shops |
Tubes are filled hot on a filling tray, 50 at a time, capped once set and labeled the next day. How long a tube keeps is in lip balm shelf life.
The label
A lip balm's label carries what it is, the net weight (21 CFR 701.13), the ingredients in descending order (21 CFR 701.3) and the name and place of business (21 CFR 701.12); on a panel of 5 square inches or less, the net weight doesn't have to sit in the bottom 30%. A claim like SPF or healing makes it a drug. What else the label needs is in cosmetic labeling requirements. This is general information, not legal advice.
An example: four options for an apothecary
Elder & Oak Apothecary, the made-up apothecary in Pennsylvania I use in these examples, fills about 150 tubes a week for markets, online orders and gift shops:
| Option | Parts | Per package | 150 a week |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plastic tube and label | Tube 25¢, label 10¢ | $0.36 | $53.55 |
| Paperboard push-up tube | Tube 55¢, label 10¢ | $0.67 | $100.28 |
| Slide tin | Tin 60¢, lid label 8¢ | $0.69 | $104.04 |
| Tube in a display box of 24 | Tube, label, a 24th of a $1.20 box | $0.41 | $61.05 |
Markets and online orders get the plastic tube; gift shops get the same tubes in a display box, which adds 5 cents a tube and sits by their register. The paperboard tube costs nearly twice as much and needed a firmer recipe, so it's kept for one shop that sells only plastic-free goods. What each tube keeps is in lip balm profit margin.
Get the calculator
Download the lip balm packaging calculator. Two sheets: components, each part of each option with its pack price, units, how many a package uses and waste; and compare, each option's cost per package and per week at your volume, with notes. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
A cost sheet doesn't know how many tubes are left, or which batch went into which display box. When a shop reports a reaction, the batch behind that tube has to be found.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps each batch's lot, the packaging in its cost, and where every case went.
Each batch a lot. Each batch of balm records the ingredient lots it used, gets its own lot and dates, and lot labels print for the packages.
Packaging in the recipe. The tubes, labels and boxes are items in each flavor's recipe, so every batch uses them up at the price you paid, and the count of what's left stays current.
Where it went. Each customer's order records the lots it got, so one recall report shows every customer a batch reached.
| The job | Notebook | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Which batch is in a package | Written on it | The lot on its label |
| Tubes, labels and boxes left | Counted when you run out | Used by every batch |
| Which shops got a batch | Invoices | One recall report |
Lots, batches, recipes and true cost are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
